← All posts

How LICAT aligns solvency with IFRS reporting: Part 4, Leases

Anubhav Chattoraj, Founder & Director · 18 November 2026 · 6 min read

Background

As discussed in the earlier articles in this series1, IRDAI has indicated that it intends to align India’s proposed Risk-Based Capital (RBC) framework with financial reporting under Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS). The objective is to use a common balance sheet for financial reporting and solvency assessment, subject to any adjustments that solvency measurement requires.

One consequence of this alignment concerns leases. Indian insurers typically lease a substantial number of office premises. The recognition of these leases as assets and liabilities under Ind AS 116 (IFRS 16) raises questions about their treatment under an Ind AS-aligned RBC framework.

How leases are treated under Ind AS

AS 19 of the existing Indian GAAP distinguishes finance leases from operating leases. A lessee recognises an asset and corresponding obligation for a finance lease. For an operating lease, such as most insurance companies’ office premises, the lessee generally recognises rental expense over the lease term, rather than recognising the leased property and the commitment to make future lease payments on its balance sheet.

Ind AS 116 (IFRS 16) takes a different approach. With exceptions for certain short-term leases and leases of low-value assets, the lessee recognises two items at commencement:

  • A right-of-use (ROU) asset, representing its right to use the underlying property during the lease term; and
  • A lease liability (LL), representing the present value of future lease payments.

At lease commencement, recognising the lease increases reported assets and liabilities by the same amount, without impacting equity. The amounts can diverge thereafter, but the net impact on equity is ordinarily much smaller than either gross balance.

How LICAT treats leases

Canada’s Life Insurance Capital Adequacy Test (LICAT) starts from financial information prepared under IFRS. Its treatment of lease accounting therefore offers a relevant precedent for India.2

Available capital resources

LICAT’s Tier 1 capital starts with accounting equity components, including adjusted retained earnings, and then applies specified regulatory adjustments. There is no general adjustment that reverses an insurer’s ROU assets or its corresponding lease liabilities. Consequently, the net difference between the ROU asset and lease liability flows through to available capital through accounting equity.3

Required capital

LICAT applies real estate risk charges to ROU assets, similar to those that would be applied to owned properties.4

Further, we understand that LICAT also subjects lease liabilities to interest rate risk charges based on the actual liability cash flows.5 (This is based on our reading of LICAT and has not been verified from market practitioners.) This is in spite of the fact that lease liabilities are carried in the financial statements at a locked-in interest rate, and is similar to LICAT’s treatment of amortized cost assets.

The impact of lease liabilities on the overall interest-rate risk requirement may be positive or negative, depending on the insurer’s other exposures.

The capital charge on lease liabilities need not offset the capital charge on the ROU asset. These are effectively two independent charges, calculated using separate methodologies.

Thus both balances may lead to an increase in required capital, even though they largely offset each other in available capital (and on the balance sheet).

Comparison with India’s QIS 2

IRDAI’s QIS 2 (Quantitative Impact Study 2) framework for RBC takes a different starting point. It requires assets to be valued on a fair-value basis in accordance with Ind AS 113, except where specific valuation rules apply. It is not clear whether ROU assets are also to be valued; in practice, most Indian insurers have only considered Indian GAAP assets (revalued to reflect their fair value) in their RBC submissions. 6

Applying the LICAT approach would generally increase the capital requirements of Indian insurers as compared to QIS 2’s approach, since the introduction of ROU assets and lease liability would have an impact on the required capital. On the other hand, the net impact on available capital would generally be comparatively small because ROU assets and lease liabilities tend to be similar in value.

The way forward for India

An Ind AS-aligned RBC framework has three broad choices for leases:

Approach Available capital Required capital
1. Follow LICAT Include both ROU assets and lease liabilities Property-risk charge on the ROU asset; interest-rate stress on the lease liability
2. Recognise, but do not stress Include both balances No direct capital requirement on either balance
3. Exclude lease accounting effects Ignore both balances for solvency purposes No ROU or lease-liability capital requirement

Approach 1 maintains consistency between owned and leased properties, but could impose additional capital charges on ROU assets and lease liabilities.45

Approach 2 preserves a common Ind AS balance sheet without introducing additional capital requirements for leases.

Approach 3 is closest to the current QIS 2 approach and avoids additional lease-related capital requirements. While this would require an adjustment to the Ind AS balance sheet for solvency purposes, this adjustment would be a straightforward and not require significant additional effort to produce or explain.6

The appropriate treatment will depend on how India balances consistency with Ind AS reporting against the economic risks that the RBC framework is intended to capture.

Footnotes

  1. See Part 1: CSM, Part 2: PAA, and Part 3: Debt instruments in this series. ↩

  2. Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI), LICAT Guideline (2025), section 1.3 (basis for calculations), read with footnote 5. ↩

  3. OSFI, LICAT Chapter 2, sections 2.1.1 and 2.1.2 (Gross Tier 1, adjusted retained earnings and deductions). Neither section prescribes a general reversal of IFRS 16 ROU assets and lease liabilities. ↩

  4. OSFI, LICAT Section 3.1.9 mentions that “Where a life insurer is the lessee, the capital requirement for the associated asset held on the balance sheet is based on the underlying property leased per section 5.3.” LICAT section 5.3 pertains to real estate risk (under market risk). For owner-occupied property, the capital requirement is generally the positive excess of the relevant historical-cost measure (after depreciation) over 70% of current fair value. Where fair value is not available, the requirement is 30% of carrying value. ↩ ↩2

  5. OSFI, LICAT Chapter 5, sections 5.1 and 5.1.3. Section 5.1 measures changes in the present value of asset and liability cash flows under prescribed discount-rate scenarios; section 5.1.3.12 expressly excludes items recognised in available capital from liability cash-flow projections. The list of exclusions does not include lease liabilities. ↩ ↩2

  6. IRDAI, Indian Risk Based Capital Framework – Quantitative Impact Study 2: Technical Guidance, August 2025, section 4.1. While section 4.1 includes leasehold land in available capital, this is not clearly relevant for Indian insurance companies, most of whose leased assets are office units and not land. ↩ ↩2