Background
As mentioned in Part 1, IRDAI1 is considering using a common balance sheet for Ind AS2 financial reporting and solvency assessment. This approach would reduce the need to carry out and reconcile multiple valuations, but it also requires resolving differences between how accounting measures an insurer’s liabilities and how a regulator assesses its financial strength. Canada’s Life Insurance Capital Adequacy Test (LICAT), which uses IFRS financial statements as its starting point, provides a useful precedent for examining how this can work in practice.
The first article in this series examined how LICAT recognises the Contractual Service Margin (CSM) as available capital. The accounting liability includes unearned profit (CSM); LICAT identifies that profit separately and makes it available to support the insurer’s solvency position.
In this article, we explore what happens when the accounting model does not identify that profit separately.
That is the case for contracts measured under the Premium Allocation Approach (PAA). LICAT accepts this simplification, but does not give the implicit margins within the PAA liability the same recognition as explicit CSM and risk adjustment under the General Measurement Model (GMM) or the Variable Fee Approach (VFA).
We also consider what would happen if India adopted LICAT’s treatment of PAA while retaining the capital charge structure proposed in QIS 2 of Indian RBC. This helps distinguish the effects of the liability measurement approach from those of the capital formulas.
What is PAA?
PAA is an optional, simplified approach to liability measurement permitted by IFRS 17 / Ind AS 117 in certain scenarios. It simplifies the measurement of liability for remaining coverage (LRC): the obligation to provide insurance services for the unexpired part of a contract. LRC broadly resembles the Unearned Premium Reserve (UPR) used today for annual group life policies and most non-life and health business.
PAA’s simplification concerns future coverage. Claims that have already occurred, including those not yet reported, sit in the liability for incurred claims (LIC), which is measured in a substantially similar way under PAA and GMM.
Broadly, PAA is intended to approximate GMM. IFRS 17 / Ind AS 117 permits it where the insurer reasonably expects that the resulting LRC would not differ materially from GMM. There is also an automatic eligibility route where every contract in the group has a coverage period of one year or less.
PAA is widely used in non-life and standalone health insurance, while its application within life insurance is more concentrated in specific types of products (such as annual group protection covers) which do not form a major part of most life insurance companies’ business.
How LICAT handles PAA
Section 1.4.4 of LICAT draws an explicit distinction3:
| Accounting model | LICAT treatment of the remaining-coverage liability |
|---|---|
| GMM / VFA | Best estimate liability excludes the separately identified risk adjustment (RA) and contractual service margin (CSM). |
| PAA | The reported LRC is treated as the best estimate liability. |
For PAA, LICAT also defines proxy cash flows: projected releases of LRC into insurance revenue are treated as outflows, with future premium receipts treated as inflows.
The insurer therefore does not have to calculate a GMM liability simply to replace its PAA balance for solvency purposes. Requiring that calculation would undermine the operational benefit of choosing PAA in the first place.
The capital consequence of simplicity
LICAT’s treatment of PAA has an adverse impact on insurance companies’ solvency positions, for reasons that we discuss below.
Reduction in available capital resources
PAA broadly works by equating the initial liability with the policy premium, and amortising it over the duration of the policy.
For profitable business, the premium (and therefore the LRC under PAA) also contains implicit margins for uncertainty and profit, even though these are not separately measured as RA and CSM.
Treating the whole PAA LRC as best estimate liability has the effect of including these margins within the regulatory liability.
Consider the following simplified comparison. Assume identical assets and total accounting liabilities, with no incurred claims, reinsurance, tax effects or other regulatory adjustments. Under GMM, the liability of 100 comprises best estimate liability (BEL) of 70, RA of 10 and CSM of 20. Under PAA, the LRC is also 100.
| Component | GMM | PAA |
|---|---|---|
| Assets | 150 | 150 |
| Total accounting liability | 100 | 100 |
| Accounting equity | 50 | 50 |
| Explicit CSM added to available capital | 20 | 0 |
| Available capital | 70 | 50 |
| Explicit RA recognised as surplus allowance under LICAT | 10 | 0 |
| Available capital + surplus allowance | 80 | 50 |
LICAT adds eligible CSM to adjusted retained earnings. Separately, its Total Ratio (solvency ratio) numerator includes a “surplus allowance” based on the reported net RA.3
In the above example, using PAA as a measurement model instead of GMM wipes out 30 units from the numerator of the solvency ratio, effectively reducing available capital (and surplus allowance) by 37.5%.
Increase in counterparty default capital charges
Both LICAT and QIS 2 of Indian RBC calculate reinsurance default capital charges by applying prescribed factors to reinsurance exposures.3 Under QIS 2, the factors vary with the reinsurer’s credit rating and categorisation.4
Under GMM, the best-estimate reinsurance recoverable represents expected recoveries less expected reinsurance premiums payable, excluding the separately identified RA and CSM. Under PAA, the asset for remaining coverage is instead based on the allocation of reinsurance premiums over the coverage period. Like the corresponding direct insurance liability, this balance can contain implicit margins.
If Indian RBC adopts LICAT’s approach of treating PAA balances as best estimates, these implicit margins would remain within the premium-related reinsurance exposure. A larger PAA exposure would attract a higher capital charge, even though the underlying reinsurance arrangement and the reinsurer’s credit quality are unchanged.
Consider the following simplified example, with positive exposures after reinsurance premiums payable and no collateral:
| Component | GMM best-estimate basis | PAA basis |
|---|---|---|
| Premium-related reinsurance exposure | 70 | 100 |
| Applicable default factor | 3% | 3% |
| Default capital charge | 2.10 | 3.00 |
The additional charge of 0.90 arises because the PAA exposure includes margins that are separately identified and excluded under GMM. This is another capital cost of the simplification: implicit margins can both reduce the recognition of available capital and increase the exposure attracting reinsurance default charges.
Near-miss: Life insurance capital charges
QIS 2 calculates life insurance risk capital by measuring the increase in BEL under prescribed stresses. Treating the entire PAA LRC as BEL could therefore increase capital charges.
However, where the insurer does not use explicit mortality or morbidity assumptions in its liability valuation, LICAT allows the relevant charges to be calculated using “adjusted net premiums”, which incorporate the expected claims loss ratio, rather than applying the shocks to the entire premium-based liability.3
This is particularly relevant when considered alongside India’s existing valuation requirements. The existing regulations5 prescribe Gross Premium Valuation, with exceptions for:
-
One-year renewable group term assurances, including riders attached to group business, where reserves allow for unearned premium, premium deficiency and IBNR claims.
-
Riders attached to individual products, where the reserve must be the higher of the Gross Premium Valuation reserve and the Unearned Premium Reserve.
These segments are also the principal candidates for PAA within a life insurer’s portfolio.
Adopting LICAT’s alternative calculations for these contracts would therefore avoid stressing the implicit margins within the PAA LRC. For otherwise equivalent exposures and assumptions, choosing PAA would consequently not be expected to increase these charges.
Near-miss: Non-life insurance capital charges
Non-life premium risk is calculated by multiplying a premium volume measure by a prescribed line-of-business factor. It does not apply a stress directly to the premium reserve.6
This volume measure is based on past and future premium earnings on contracts already existing on the valuation date and expected to be written by the insurance company over the following year.
The earned premium is not expected to differ significantly between PAA and GMM. The choice of measurement model would therefore not be expected to have any direct effect on the non-life premium risk charge.
Further, QIS 2’s reserve risk charge is separately based on best estimate claims liabilities, which are largely identical between PAA and GMM.7
A prudential nudge towards GMM?
As seen above, under LICAT’s approach, adoption of PAA would be expected to have an adverse impact on an insurance company’s capital position through reduction in available capital and increase in reinsurance default exposure.
This effectively creates a trade-off: Reducing accounting complexity using PAA results in a weaker solvency position.
It may be argued that this is an advantage from a prudential standpoint. GMM provides a more up-to-date and fine-grained view of the company’s liabilities. A regulator may therefore reasonably choose to nudge insurance companies towards adopting GMM, and the LICAT approach serves as such a nudge. (However, it is not clear whether this was the intended purpose; we have not been able to find any documented reasons from OSFI8 for adopting this approach.)
This is of particular relevance to non-life and standalone health insurance companies, which are extensive users of PAA. All nine such companies that have published Ind AS financials for June 2026 measure their insurance business entirely under PAA.
For India, the consequence of adopting LICAT’s approach would therefore extend beyond aligning the accounting and solvency balance sheets. It would also affect the relative economics of the accounting models. Given the extensive use of PAA in non-life and standalone health insurance, this would be a material feature of the new framework and should be considered explicitly in its design.
Footnotes
-
The Indian insurance regulator, the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India ↩
-
Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) are India’s accounting standards, notified under the Companies Act, 2013 and substantially converged with International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS). Ind AS 117, governing insurance contracts, is based on IFRS 17. ↩
-
OSFI, Life Insurance Capital Adequacy Test (LICAT) Guideline, 2025, sections 1.4.4 (best estimate liabilities and PAA), 2.1.1 (CSM within available capital), 1.1.3 (risk adjustment and surplus allowance), 3.1.7 (registered reinsurance credit risk), and 6.2 and 6.4 (mortality and morbidity risk calculations). ↩ ↩2 ↩3 ↩4
-
Whether the reinsurer is an Indian reinsurer, a foreign reinsurance branch or a cross-border reinsurer. ↩
-
IRDAI (Actuarial, Finance and Investment Functions of Insurers) Regulations, 2024 (English version follows Hindi version). Schedule I, Part III, paragraph (A)(2)(6). ↩
-
QIS 2 Technical Guidance, paragraph 11.2.3.3 (pages 70–71). The reserve risk volume measure is the best estimate claim liability net of reinsurance, floored at zero. ↩
-
Canada’s Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions ↩
In this article